Ash dieback in hedgerow trees: what to look for, how to assess each tree, and what to do about it
Ash is one of the most common hedgerow trees in east Kent farmland, and it is now under serious pressure from ash dieback (Hymenoscyphus fraxineus). The disease does not kill every tree at the same pace, and hedgerow ash in an open, airy field boundary often deteriorates more slowly than woodland ash. That means the right approach is a tree-by-tree assessment, not a blanket removal, and that assessment has a clear before and after of its own.
Before
A hedgerow with ash dieback beginning to show looks, at a glance, like it might just be a dry summer: a few branches with sparse canopy in late July, some dead shoot tips, an ash that still has most of its leaves but lacks the full, dense crown it had five years ago. Look closer and the signs are more specific: the characteristic diamond-shaped bark lesions at the base of dying shoots, dead branch tips that curl slightly rather than just drying off, and in some trees the basal epicormic growth (new shoots sprouting from the lower trunk, which the tree throws when the crown is failing). A hedgerow running along field boundaries around Shatterling, Wingham or Adisham could easily have three or four ash trees in a fifty-metre run, at different stages of decline, with one barely touched and the one next to it showing 60% crown death already.
After
A managed hedgerow ash line, two or three years on from a proper assessment and removal programme, looks noticeably tidier and safer: the worst-affected trees are gone, replaced by a mix of field maple, hawthorn or hazel at a stocking rate high enough to close the visual and stock-proofing gap within a few growing seasons. The trees that were retained because their crown dieback was low and their risk category was acceptable are still there, still monitored, contributing their ecological value, and the hedge line has continuity rather than a string of stumps and bare sky. The before was uncertainty and a slow creeping problem. The after is a managed situation rather than an unmanaged one.
The three-stage assessment
The Forestry Commission's guidance for individual non-woodland ash (Operations Note 46a) is written for land managers, including householders, with ash in hedgerows, verges and gardens. It expects most ash to be badly affected over the coming years, says there is no known efficient cure, and treats the consequences of a failure (what the tree could fall on) as central to the decision. That frames a three-stage assessment that I use when walking a hedge line for a landowner or householder.
- Stage 1: Walk the line and score each tree. In late July or August, when the canopy should be at its fullest, walk the hedge with a rough scoring sheet and mark each ash with an approximate crown dieback percentage: healthy crown is 0-10% dead, light dieback is 10-30%, moderate is 30-50%, severe is above 50%. This is not a formal arborist survey, it is a working triage. For a field boundary hedge, I look at each tree in full leaf and note which category it falls into, and whether there is anything the tree could strike if it failed: a footpath, a lane, a building, stock or vehicles. An ash with 40% crown dieback in the middle of a large arable field is a different management problem from an ash with the same crown condition next to a public footpath across a footpath, or along The Street in Staple.
- Stage 2: Sort each tree into a category: retain, monitor or remove. This is my own working triage, not an official standard. Trees with less than 30% crown dieback, no structural failure signs (no significant deadwood loading, no large cracks at major branch junctions), and nothing valuable within their fall zone are candidates to retain and reassess next summer. Trees with 30-50% dieback where the risk is manageable go on a monitor list, revisited in six to twelve months, because progression is variable and the Forestry Commission notes that mortality has been seen in as little as two growing seasons. Trees with more than 50% crown dieback, or any ash within falling distance of a path, lane or building, are candidates for removal sooner rather than later. The cost of waiting is not just the tree's condition, it is the cost of managing a tree that has become a safety hazard rather than simply a diseased one.
- Stage 3: Licence, replace and plan ahead. Felling a growing ash, even a diseased one, normally needs a felling licence from the Forestry Commission under the Forestry Act 1967 unless an exception applies (a tree in a garden, churchyard, orchard or public open space, or a genuinely dangerous tree meeting the Commission's criteria), so check before anyone cuts. Tree felling is specialist work for a qualified tree surgeon and is not something I do; my part is the hedge: each removed ash leaves a gap that needs filling. The Commission says ash itself must not be replanted at present because of the embargo on ash plant movements, and advises restocking with a variety of site-suitable species. Field maple, hawthorn and hazel are the natives I would reach for in an east Kent hedge, planted as bare-root stock in the bare-root window (October to February) so the replacements get several growing seasons before the gap becomes a problem for stock or privacy.
Nesting birds and ash removal: what the law requires
Ash trees in a farmland hedgerow are actively used for nesting, and ash dieback does not change that. The Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981, section 1, makes it an offence to intentionally damage or destroy a wild bird's nest while it is in use or being built, and the practical caution window runs from 1 March to 31 August, with late broods sometimes extending that into September. Farmland hedgerows around Staple and Shatterling suit birds such as yellowhammer and linnet, which nest in thick native hedge structure, and an ash with a failing crown can still hold nests in its lower, heavier branches. Any work planned between March and August should be preceded by a pre-work check by someone who knows what a live nest looks like. September to February is the practical window for most hedgerow ash work.
What the assessment does not replace
This three-stage process is a working triage for a land manager or householder who wants to understand what they are looking at before they call anyone. It is not a formal tree survey or a qualified risk assessment, and for any ash tree next to a road, a public right of way, or a building, a written assessment from a qualified arborist is the right starting point, both for the safety decision and for any insurance or duty-of-care purposes. The triage tells you where to start looking and roughly what you are dealing with. The formal assessment is what you want in hand before anyone puts a chainsaw into a tree next to a house or a public path.
A note on tolerant ash
The Forestry Commission expects the majority of ash trees to die or be significantly affected in the coming years, but not every tree declines at the same pace. Some ash trees appear able to tolerate infection, and the Commission suggests that crown reduction or lopping, rather than felling, and natural regeneration can help favour more tolerant strains. A hedgerow ash that still carries a good crown after several summers is worth marking, photographing and monitoring rather than removing in a hurry, because it may be one of the more tolerant individuals. Losing a tolerant ash to an over-cautious clearance is a genuine cost.
Related guides
- Removing ivy from farmland hedgerow trees: before, four stages, and the readable trunk after
- Establishing hedgerow standard trees on farmland: from a flat boundary to a working hedge with oak and field maple
- Renovating an overgrown hawthorn hedge: before and after
- Planting a new native hedge on farmland: bare plot to established hedge
Ash in your hedgerow you are worried about?
Send a couple of photos and the location to hello@staplehedges.co.uk or call 07763 100 477. I can do a walk-and-score assessment on a hedge line and tell you honestly which trees need to come out now, which ones to watch, and what to replant with.
Sources: Forestry Commission, "Managing ash trees affected by ash dieback: Operations Note 46a" (gov.uk); Forestry Commission, "Managing ash dieback in England" (gov.uk); Forestry Act 1967, section 9 (felling licences); Wildlife and Countryside Act 1981, section 1.